1. 

   1Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham

   101 reviews

   Nice boutique hotel. Friendly and helpful staff. The rooms were big and comfortable. Slept well so very quiet. Plenty of amenities. Definitely a good choice.

   Guest review on Trip.com

   fromUS$175per night

   Check pricesMore info
2. 

   2The Inn at Fox Hollow Hotel

   103 reviews

   fromUS$213per night

   Check pricesMore info
3. 

   3Best Western Bar Harbour Inn

   111 reviews

   By far the best rooms great people great

   Guest review on Trip.com

   fromUS$127per night

   Check pricesMore info
4. 

   4Best Western Woodbury Inn

   106 reviews

   fromUS$96per night

   Check pricesMore info
5. 

   5Tides Inn at Stehli Beach

   103 reviews

   fromUS$83per night

   Check pricesMore info
6. 

   6Days Inn by Wyndham Woodbury Long Island

   102 reviews

   fromUS$114per night

   Check pricesMore info
7. 

   74 BR. 2 BTH, HOT TUB, MINS TO JONES BEACH, MINS TO RIVIERA WALK TO TRAIN TO NYC

   13 reviews

   Booking is completed on Trip.com

   Check pricesMore info
8. 

   8Cozy New Apartment in North Massapequa

   19 reviews

   Booking is completed on Trip.com

   Check pricesMore info
9. 

   9Great Family Times In this lovely Cape with Resort style backyard

   20 reviews

   Booking is completed on Trip.com

   Check pricesMore info

Compare all 9 hotels in Oyster Bay

Indicative lowest prices collected from Trip.com on Sep 26, 2026. The live price depends on your dates and is shown on Trip.com.